29 replies to this topic

[The Red Baron]

Well, it seems our alchemists couldn't decide on a lynch before the sun went down. Sucks for them.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The discussion continued, becoming more and more passionate as time went on. At one point, in a fit of anger at not being able to decide anything, and with the threat of a murderer at hand, Dave actually tore down his tent (strong huh. that thing was held up with the strongest sticks known to man ) Luckily monogodo was able to calm him down before the whole campsiste went up in flames. With tensions running high. The group returned to their tents for a fitful sleep. All except Navarre, that is, who stayed behind to watch the fire and clean up.

Noone said anything that morning. There was nothing anyone could say to comfort the fear of those around. For the murder(s) had struck again. It was a difficult sight to look at, Navarre, covered in blood. There were no wounds on his body, just blood. A magical attack that was covered up? Or an unexplained injury?

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Navarre was killed and he was:
Innocent

9 people left
5 votes to lynch

[Navarre]

You forgot to mention that I even make death look good.

[Dave]

I thought simple majority wasn't required to lynch until there were 6 or fewer players left.

I still vote Meathe.
Vote to lynch: Meathe

current tally:
Ahriman
Bacony Goodness
Chad
Malfouka
McAwesome
Meathe - 1
Monogodo
Treeman
Webkittyn

[The Red Baron]

I wasn't sure about votes, so simple is the way to go.

[Dave]

What I mean is: this (about two thirds of the way down) "What if there's a tie in the lynching phase?"

[Dave]

Wait, Navarre wasn't a mafia hit?

[Don Corleone]

...

Edited by Don Corleone, 23 July 2009 - 10:48 PM.

[monogodo]

WK: Don't lynch yourself, there's nothing wrong with being confused. It's been a while since we played, and there are some new people here playing & running the game. There are many different ways of handling lynchings in case of a tie in this game. The way we've always done it is the first to the tie total is the one who is lynched. At USG, the lynched party is randomly chosen from those who tie.

I'm guessing that based on the below quote from TRB, since there was no majority D1, there was no lynch. I'm further guessing that if we want to lynch someone D2, that person needs 5 votes.

Well, it seems our alchemists couldn't decide on a lynch before the sun went down. Sucks for them.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

9 people left
5 votes to lynch

[Chad]

Posts purged per request, mine along with a few others, to avoid further confusion.

Current tally:

Ahriman
Bacony Goodness
Chad
Malfouka
McAwesome
Meathe - 1
Monogodo
Treeman
Webkittyn

[monogodo]

Dave's logic with regards to Meathe's actions D1 is still sound to me.

So unless I'm convinced otherwise:

Vote to Lynch: Meathe

Current tally:

Ahriman
Bacony Goodness
Chad
Malfouka
McAwesome
Meathe - 2
monogodo
Treeman
Webkittyn

[The Red Baron]

The tie was at 3 votes. Not enough to make a lynch. I warned 24 hours before that the day would end even if there was no lynch. Yes, i should have been more clear on the votes first roun. sorry. your right mono. No majority so no lynch. Five votes to lynch today!

Edited by The Red Baron, 24 July 2009 - 12:55 AM.

[WebKittyn]

I have nothing to go on but hunch so hunch it is.

Vote to lynch Ahriman

Current tally:

Ahriman - 1
Bacony Goodness
Chad
Malfouka
McAwesome
Meathe - 2
monogodo
Treeman
Webkittyn

[Chad]

Vote to lynch Bacon for his continued evil Wii and PS3 ways.

Current tally:

Ahriman - 1
Bacony Goodness - 1
Chad
Malfouka
McAwesome
Meathe - 2
monogodo
Treeman
Webkittyn

Still early. I got nothing yet.

Edited by Chad, 24 July 2009 - 03:56 PM.

[Meathe]

Mono's "It would be a mistake to lynch me" comment rankled a bit. He's surely not outing himself as the cop. Misdirection, perhaps?

Ahriman - 1
Bacony Goodness - 1
Chad
Malfouka
McAwesome
Meathe - 2
monogodo - 1
Treeman
Webkittyn

And please, no more ties. It just helps them whack people without even a chance of stringing one up

[Chad]

Mono's "It would be a mistake to lynch me" comment rankled a bit. He's surely not outing himself as the cop. Misdirection, perhaps?

I am always suspicious of revenge votes after the first day.

Unvote Bacon and vote to lynch Meathe

Ahriman - 1
Bacony Goodness
Chad
Malfouka
McAwesome
Meathe - 3
monogodo - 1
Treeman
Webkittyn

Edited by Chad, 24 July 2009 - 11:16 PM.

[Treeman]

Vote for Mono

Ahriman - 1
Bacony Goodness - 1
Chad
Malfouka
McAwesome
Meathe - 2
monogodo - 2
Treeman
Webkittyn

[monogodo]

Mono's "It would be a mistake to lynch me" comment rankled a bit. He's surely not outing himself as the cop. Misdirection, perhaps?

Ahriman - 1
Bacony Goodness - 1
Chad
Malfouka
McAwesome
Meathe - 2
monogodo - 1
Treeman
Webkittyn

And please, no more ties. It just helps them whack people without even a chance of stringing one up

You need to state in bold type who your vote is for, as it helps the townspeople.

I am always suspicious of revenge votes after the first day.

Unvote Bacon and vote to lynch Meathe

Ahriman - 1
Bacony Goodness - 1
Chad
Malfouka
McAwesome
Meathe - 3
monogodo - 1
Treeman
Webkittyn

You forgot to deduct BG's vote from his tally.

Current Tally:

Ahriman - 1
Bacony Goodness
Chad
Malfouka
McAwesome
Meathe - 3
monogodo - 2
Treeman
Webkittyn

EDIT: I copied Chad's vote totals, which didn't include Treeman's vote.

Edited by monogodo, 24 July 2009 - 11:15 PM.

[Chad]

You forgot to deduct BG's vote from his tally.

Apologies.

[Ahriman]

Interesting that you would have hunches about me Webkittyn,as i have hunches about you. Two people went to the baron's aid the on the first day. One i think from concern, And the other to cover their guilt. As I know my own innocence, one of the culprits must be you. My evidence is not completely sound, but your vote to lynch me reinforces my notion.

Vote to lynch: Webkittyn

Ahriman - 1
Bacony Goodness
Chad
Malfouka
McAwesome
Meathe - 3
monogodo - 2
Treeman
Webkittyn -1

[monogodo]

Interesting that you would have hunches about me Webkittyn,as i have hunches about you. Two people went to the baron's aid the on the first day. One i think from concern, And the other to cover their guilt. As I know my own innocence, one of the culprits must be you. My evidence is not completely sound, but your vote to lynch me reinforces my notion.

Your evidence is shit. I used the same logic D1 as a joke excuse to vote for her. The narrator, not WK, stated that she went to the Baron's aid. He could just as easily stated that you and Meathe went to his aid. Or me and Dave. Or Bacon & Chad.